Marketing 101: Selecting An Overall Positioning Strategy - Value Proposition

There are buzz words and phrases in marketing & branding that seem to have an "aura" or "mystery" revolving around them.  There are also phrases and words that people who have careers in marketing don't understand at all.  One of the most used terms in existence is the Value Proposition.  Yet, so many of my colleagues don't really know what one is, or how to use it.  So let's spend some time defining it and exploring what it is and how you use it.

What Is A Value Proposition?
Simple question, right? Yet...it's a bit of a complicated answer. So if I'm going to define this as simply as possible, I'm going to say it like this: A Value Proposition is the full positioning of a brand, product or service.  If I were to expand on the definition, then I would say that a Value Proposition is the full mix of benefits that the brand, product, or service is differentiated and positioned upon.  A Value Proposition answers the question: "Why should I buy this?"

Above is a fairly standard illustration of the matrix of Value Propositions.  On the top, we have three Price categories: More, The Same, and Less.  On the side, we have three Benefits categories: More, The Same, and Less.  So when we assemble a Value Proposition, we are pairing a level of Benefit, with a level of Price.  For example, I may choose to take a More for the Same approach, meaning I'm going to offer more features and benefits than my competitors, for the same price.

The combinations in the matrix that are green represent the most favorable approaches to take with your Value Proposition.  Those in red are rarely profitable, and tend to lead to problems or a loss of focus down the road.

Let's begin exploring some of these categories of Value Proposition.

More For More
When we tout a "More For More" value proposition, we are telling the consumer that we are providing them the best possible product or service, and we are charging a higher (some would say "premium") price to cover the costs of giving you the "best".

In the real world, it is easy to see who the "More For More" players are.  One of my favorites is Apple.  They are not shy about "More For More". Apple gives you the best design, the best quality, the best experience, at a price that meets their corporate goals for gross margins and profits.  When a company truly stands behind this value proposition, giving the consumer a premium product, with premium service and an experience that is consistent over time (the Macintosh has been around for 30 years), then it can be very successful.

In order to compete in a "More For More" market segment, you are going to have to find a product or service category that is under-serviced.  If there is a void in the market segment for a premium product, and if the market segment has consumers that can afford a premium product, then you can consider moving in to that area.  However, there are cons to following a "More For More" value proposition.  When you have a premium product, there will always be imitators that will produce a similar product or service, and claim that it has the same quality for a lower price.  Amazon has been marketing it's Kindle Fire HD as a higher quality, lower priced alternative to Apple's iPad Air tablet.  "More For More" brands, products and services will always be under fire by those who use a "More For The Same" or "The Same For Less" value proposition.

More For The Same
How do you counter a "More For More" competitor?  You present a "More For The Same" value proposition.  A "More For The Same" value proposition entales offering a product, service or brand with comparable quality, at a lower price.  Depending on the costs associated with producing your product or service, you may have the same margins as a "More For More" competitor, or you have have smaller margins, which you are hoping to make up for with a higher volume of sales.

What does "More For The Same" look like in the marketplace?  The auto industry is a great example. Lexus, Infinity, Kia and Hyundai are perfect examples.  Lexus and Infinity were the first to attempt to uproot major luxury "More For More" brands such as Mercedes, BMW and Cadillac.  Offering more car, for the same (and usually lower price), these brands were able to take away more and more market share. As a result, Mercedes and BMW realized that there were more customers available at lower price points.  More recently, Hyundai and Kia have followed the same approach, introducing their Genesis and Cadenza models to the marketplace.  However, "More For The Same" can fail, if you are not backing up your value proposition with the quality and features that you claim you are providing the consumer.

The Same For Less
Probably the most powerful Value Proposition is "The Same For Less". Why?  Because we all love getting a great deal.  Great product?  Lower price?  Yes please!  Need a high quality PC for less?  Get a Dell.  Need great quality food, clothes, and electronics?  Go to Costco.  Want door busting deals on name brand electronics?  Go to Best Buy or Fry's Electronics.  Need name brand groceries for much less?  Go to Winco.  You get the idea.

Less For Much Less
If you remember my discussion of social and economic groups, then you know the reality of the consumer: few people want, need, or can even afford the very best products and services.  As a result, there will always be a market for value products.  "Less For Much Less" is summed up with a definition of "offering a brand, product, or service of less quality, for a lower price".   In most cases, the reality of a consumer's monthly budget forces a consumer to stick with "needs" over "wants" during the buyer decision process.

This means you are going to provide a lower "performing" product (less quality and features), at a much lower price.  This also means that you are usually relying on a higher volume of sales to make up for much lower margins.

More For Less
I'm going to briefly touch on one Value Propositional tactic that we see fairly often in the marketplace.  "More For Less".  That's what we all want, right?  More features, more product, more value, for a really low price.  We typically see "More For Less" when a new brand is entering a target market with established players.  Many claim to offer "More For Less" today.

At first it's easy to do.  You are ripe with new investment capital, or you are a large company that has just budgeted a large amount of money towards a new product segment. So you market your product, and sometimes sell it at a loss, offering more features, for a better price.  However, over time, it becomes very hard to maintain a "More For Less" value proposition.  Companies will typically fall into this trap: losing focus.  With each new generation of your product, you will add more features.  All of this product development, all of this marketing, costs money.  Lots of it.  And unless you have other products in your stable that are selling well and creating profits, you will have to raise the price of your product in order to cover the costs associated with bring it to market.  If you don't, you lose money.  Not only are you losing money, but your product and your brand become so "busy" and "cluttered", you begin to lose out to your competitors, who are more focused, and have a more focused product and message.  In essence, you eventually confuse your consumers, and once your prices go up, they look elsewhere during the buying decision process.  Stay away from "More For Less", unless you can keep your focus, and you can manage your bottom line.

Read More

Marketing 101: Post-Purchase Behavior

So far I've examined four of the five stages of the Buyer Decision Process: Need Recognition, Information Search, Evaluation of Alternatives, and the actual Purchase Decision.  We've discovered that each stage is complicated, and that marketers will need to understand their customer's journey as they construct meaningful campaigns and messaging.  These statements are even more important to reckon with in the last stage of the Buyer Decision Process: Post-Purchase Behavior.

What is Post-Purchase Behavior?
Simply defined, Post-Purchase Behavior is the stage of the Buyer Decision Process when a consumer will take additional action, based purely on their satisfaction or dissatisfaction.  The consumer's level of satisfaction or dissatisfaction is directly related to the varying relationship between their initial expectations of the product (pre-purchase), and their perception of the actual performance of the product (post-purchase) in their hands.

If after the purchase the consumer perceives the product's performance as matching their expectations, or even exceeding them, they will be "satisfied".  If their perception of the product's performance is less than their expectations, then the consumer will feel "dissatisfied".  The larger the gap between their expectations and the product's performance, the more dissatisfaction.  This dissatisfaction leads to Cognitive Dissonance.

Cognitive Dissonance is buyer discomfort caused by post-purchase conflict resulting from dissatisfaction.  The reality is that all purchases, big and small, will result in some degree of Cognitive Dissonance.  This is always the case, because every purchase a consumer makes involves some sort of compromise, however small or minute.  Since consumers form beliefs and attitudes early in the Buyer Decision Process, at some point they will be concerned about having a negative experience with the product they may chose, or potentially missing the perceived benefits of other competing brands.

The issue of Cognitive Dissonance raises an important question: Why is it so important to satisfy the consumer?  It all comes back to our basic definition of marketing: Managing profitable customer relationships.  The goal is to attract new customers through superior value, and to keep growing customers by delivering customer satisfaction.  If we are doing these things, then we will be able to capture value from customers to create profits and build customer equity.  So, if our customers are satisfied they will begin to develop brand loyalty.  This brand loyalty will help us develop profitable relationships.  Our satisfied customers will buy from us again. They will become influencers in their cultural and social groups.  They will pay less attention to competitors, and buy more of our products. 

Dissatisfaction breeds the opposite.  Consumers that perceive poor product performance will not create profits and will erode customer equity.  They will not be loyal, and they will become negative influencers in their cultural and social groups, leading others away from our brands.  What should we do with dissatisfied customers?  We should pursue them.  Even if they do not want to buy our products, we can still target them with dedicated messaging.  We can directly reach out to them, and we can figure out ways to repair the relationship.  These consumers can provide us with a wealth of primary data that can be used to improve our offerings and create focused marketing campaigns.  Dissatisfied consumers are just as valuable as satisfied ones.

The conclusion is clear: Our job is not done once the consumer buys our product.  Once a consumer buys a product they will enter some degree of post-purchase behavior.  These behaviors, based on their satisfaction or dissatisfaction, will either build customer equity and brand loyalty, or lead to eroding sales and brand image issues.  This all is related to their relationship between their expectations and the perceivced performance of the products in their hands.  As marketers, we must have messaging ready for this specific part of the Buyer Decision Process.  It is our job to encourage happy consumers to share their experiences and dive deeper into brand offerings.  It is also our job to be brand advocates by reaching out to dissatisfied consumers and transforming their experience into one that leads to a profitable relationship.


Follow @macdailybites

Read More

Marketing 101: Purchase Decision

In my examination of the Buyer Decision Process I've explored the first three steps: Need Recognition, Information Search, and the Evaluation of Alternatives. Generally the completion of alternative evaluation will lead to our fourth step, the Purchase Decision.

The Purchase Decision
We can define the Purchase Decision simply as the consumer's choice of which brand to purchase.  Once the consumer forms their beliefs and attitudes about a product segment's brands, the consumer will usually purchase the most preferred brand.  Notice that I said usually.  Sometimes two factors can come between the purchase intention and the purchase decision: the attitudes of others, and unexpected situations.

Sometimes the attitudes of others can change our minds before the sales transaction. For example, someone in a family group or social group might think that you should get an Apple iPad instead of a comparable competitor's tablet device.  If this person is important enough in your life, they may exert enough "peer" pressure to cause you to suddenly alter your attitudes and beliefs, greatly reducing the chances of you buying another brand of tablet.

Your tablet purchasing decision may also be altered by our second factor: unexpected situations.  Consumers will usually form their purchase decisions based on factors such as their current income level, expected prices, and assumed product benefits.  However unexpected events often will change their original purchase intention.  Some examples of purchase altering situations are unexpected sales, competitors dropping their prices, a sudden economic downturn, or a sudden change in employment.

Marketers need to understand that their work is not done once a consumer reaches the point of making a purchase.  Because consumers can, and often will change their minds, consistent messaging needs to be placed in front of the consumer all the way up to the actual sales transaction.  Even then our job is not done.  In my next post I will explore Post-Purchase Behavior.

Follow @macdailybites

Read More

Marketing 101: The Buyer Decision Process - Information Search

In my last posted I started to discuss the Buyer Decision Process.  Simply defined, it's conducted by a consumer before, during, and after the purchase of products and services. The process consists of five defined steps or stages that typically occur in a certain order: Need recognition > Information Search > Evaluation of Alternatives > Purchase Decision > Post-Purchase Behavior.

Need Recognition refers to the instance where a consumer recognizes that a need or problem exists that needs to be satisfied.  Need Recognition is usually triggered by an internal stimuli when a particular need, such as hunger or thirst, rises to a high enough level to become a drive.  Once the need has been identified and has become a drive, the pursuit of information begins.

Information Search
Information Search is the second stage of the buyer decision process.  In this stage consumers are driven (by their drive) to search for more information related to their need.  If the drive is strong and a satisfying product is near at hand, the consumer is likely to buy it then, barely collecting any information, or skipping this stage altogether.  If the drive is not strong, the consumer will usually store their need in memory and begin an information search.  As a consumer does more research they will inevitably become aware of competing brands and products that are available for purchase. 

Appliances are a product category where consumers conduct lots of research and there is ample competition.  Let's say a consumer needs to replace their refrigerator.  Because the most effective sources of information tend to be personal in nature, a consumer might start their information search by asking members of their friends and family social and cultural groups what refrigerators they would recommend.  Next, the consumer will typically begin to use commercial sources of information to "fill in the blanks", such as advertisements, editorial reviews, and in-store sales staff.

Marketers must design their marketing mix to make target customers aware of their brand in the midst of all of this "noise".  Ad messaging must address the typical needs, lifestyle aspirations and answer the common questions of their target demographics.  Sales staff must be properly trained and incentivized so that in-store touch points are as successful as possible.  If a marketing mix is properly created, it can help accelerate consumers quickly past the Evaluation of Alternatives stage and towards the Purchase Decision.


Follow @macdailybites

Read More

Marketing 101: The Buyer Decision Process - Need Recognition

Over the past few months we've spent the majority of our time exploring the many ways consumers are influenced throughout the buying process.  First was an overview of Consumer Buying Behavior, which we placed into the Model of Consumer Buyer Behavior.  We summarized that [1] Consumers "ingest" marketing and other stimuli, such as the four P's: Product, Price, Place and Promotion [2] the stimuli enters their "buyer black box" [3] the "black box" creates buyer responses.

Next we looked at Cultural Factors affecting consumer purchases, noting that Cultural Factors are some of the strongest influences of consumer buyer behavior, because they are the set of basic values, perceptions, wants and behaviors that are "learned" by a consumer from their families and other important social institutions.  Also recall the fact that we need to remember that every group or society has a culture influencing them in some form or degree.

Along with cultural factors, there are also Social Factors affecting consumer buyer behavior.  Human beings are social, and they need people around them to interact with and to discuss various issues in order to reach better solutions and ideas.  We learned that these social factors typically consist of the consumer's small groups, their family, and their social roles and status.  We also learned about social roles such as Initiators, Influencers, Deciders, Buyers, and Users.  These roles play a part within social groups consisting of friends and familes.  We also quickly examined how economic status enables or disables a person's abilties as a consumer.

On top of the social factors affecting consumer buyer behavior, we also have Psychological Factors.  The consumer's own personality is constructed by the unique psychological characteristics that create relatively consistent, lasting behavior in response to their own environment.  These characteristics include Self Concept, Motivation and the five motivational needs, Perception, Learning, and Beliefs and Attitudes.  In summary, all of these factors and stimuli illustrate an important point: consumers are complicated.  Now let's see how complicated reaching a buying decision can be.

Defining the Buyer Decision Process
The Buyer Decision Process is conducted by a consumer before, during, and after the purchase of products and services.  Purchasing decisions are usually considered to be psychological constructs, because although we never "see" a decision, usually we infer from observed behaviors that a decision has been made. Therefore we are able to conclude that a psychological event, the "decision", has occurred. This assumption of a process suggests a commitment to action; that commitment to buy.

The Buyer Decision Process is usually split up into 5 distinct stages that typically occur in a certain order: Need recognition > Information Search > Evaluation of Alternatives > Purchase Decision > Post-Purchase Behavior.  This order seems to suggest that a consumer will pass through all five stages, however this is not always the case. Often with habitual buying behavior a consumer will usually skip or reverse some of these steps in the Buyer Decision Process.  However one step, Need Recognition, is never skipped.

Need Recognition
The first stage of the buyer decision process is Need Recognition.  Need Recognition refers to the instance where a consumer recognizes that a need or problem exists that needs to be satfisfied.  Need Recognition is usually triggered by an internal stimuli when a particular need, such as hunger or thirst, rises to a high enough level to become a drive.

External stimuli can also create a need and lead to drives.  For example, advertisements that consumers hear and see, or discussions with other people can cause them to consider buying a particular product.

When preparing a campaign and settling on your target audience, you need to conduct research that helps you define the needs of the consumer, how the needs arose, what stimuli brought them about, and how that stimuli led the consumer to determine they needed your product.

Follow @macdailybites

Read More

Marketing 101: Social Factors Affecting Consumer Buyer Behavior

In my last post I examined the cultural factors influencing consumer buyer behavior.  Cultures, subcultures and cultural trends all shape the Model of Consumer Buying Behavior.  Another major part of consumer buyer behavior is the element of Social Factors.  Human beings are social. They need people around them to interact with, and to discuss various issues in order to reach to better solutions and ideas. We all live in a society of some form, and it is very important for individuals to adhere to the "laws" and social "regulations" of a community.  These Social Factors typically consist of the consumer's small groups, their family, and their social roles and social status.

First let's examine Groups.  For the marketer, a social group is defined as having two or more people who will interact to accomplish individual or mutual goals - one of which is usually purchasing a good or service to meet a need or desire. The reality is that a consumer's behavior isn't influenced my just one group; it is influenced by many different groups.  We refer to these groups as Reference Groups.

Reference groups influence the consumer by serving as direct (face to face) or indirect points of comparison or "reference" in building a consumer's behavior and attitudes.  In a reference group with direct influence, several individuals may be a part of the consumer's purchase decision. The typical roles of these individuals are:

The Initiator

The Initiator is the individual that first suggests or thinks of the idea of buying a product or service.

The Influencer

The Influencer is the individual whose view or advice influences the consumer's buying decision.  This person is sometimes also referred to as the Opinion Leader.  The Influencer is usually has special skills or knowledge, personality or other characteristics that will exert social influence on other members of the group. The role of the Influencer or Opinion Leader has taken on a whole new meaning and emphasis with the advent of social media platforms.

The Decider

The Decider is an individual with power and/or the financial authority to make the choice regarding which product to buy.  This is usually the consumer, but it can also be another person.

Buyer

The Buyer is a person who conducts the buying transaction.  This is also usually the consumer, but it can be another person as well.

User

The User is the person (or persons) who will actually use the product or service that has been bought.

It is important to note that very often consumers are influenced by reference groups that they do not belong to.  We will sometimes refer to these groups as aspirational groups.  One example of an aspirational group would be the olympic team of the consumer's country.  The consumer may aspire, due to the success of the team members, to "be like them."  This may lead them to buy many of the same products that the team members may be endorsing, so that they can move towards their goal of acquiring many of the same traits of those group members.  Aspirational groups can exert a lot of influence over a group of consumers, and their potential to help a marketer increase sales should not be ignored.

Family Groups
Family Groups are usually considered to be the most important “buying” organisations within a given society.  Marketers are most interested in the roles and influence different members of a family group on a large variety of products and services a consumer may buy.  Over time the buying roles of the traditional husband-wife model relationship have been changing. In most societies, the wife is usually the primary buyer for the family unit, primarily in the product categories of food, household products and clothing. However, with more women entering into full-time work, and more men becoming telecommuting, traditional family roles are changing.  The challenge for the marketer is understanding how these societal changes affect demand for their products and services, and how the messaging mix might need to be changed to attract male rather than female buyers in a given product category (or vice versa).

Another factor to consider in Family Groups is the stage of life of its members.  Married individuals tend to show strong desires towards buying products and services which would benefit not only them but also the members of their family group. A consumer who has a spouse and child at home usually will buy for them rather than spending on themselves. An consumer entering into marriage would be more interested in buying a house, a car, and other household items such as furniture and decorating products.  Every consumer will usually go through a common set of stages of life, and will show a different buying mindset in each stage.  For a common male consumer this tends to look like:

• Bachelorhood: Trends towards alcohol, electronics, vehicles, mobile technology (Spends Lavishly)
• Newly Married: Trends towards purchasing a home, car, furnishings. (Spends sensibly)
• Family with Children: Trends towards purchasing products to secure the well-being of his family’s future.
• Empty Nest (Children getting married)/Retirement/Old Age: Trends towards medicines, health product categories, and products that are part of an increased lifestyle and income level.

Social Status
One aspect of social status is a consumer's economic status.  Marketers take into consideration the social class of the consumer when tailoring messaging to them.  A social class is a relatively "permanent" and ordered division in a society whose members share similar values, interests, and behaviors.  These classes have their own distinct reference groups, and often reference groups in some classes will influence consumers who are members of a different social class. Different social classes will tend to desire different categories of products as part of their consumer buyer behavior.  For example, an upper middle class consumer will tend to spend more of their disposable income on "luxury" items, whereas a consumer from middle to lower income groups will tend to purchase items that are required for their own survival over day-to-day comfort.

In the United States, there are four distinct class groups:

Upper Class (3%)
- Upper Uppers: The social elite who live on inherited wealth.  They are philanthropic, own many homes, and send their children to the best schools.
- Lower Uppers: Consumers who earn high income through great ability.  They are active in social and political culture groups, buy expensive homes, educations and vehicles.

Middle Class (44%)
- Upper Middles: Professionals and corporate managers who don't have a high family status or unusual levels of wealth.  They believe in higher education, and they want the "better things in life".
- Middle Class: "Average" income white and blue collar consumers who live in the better part of town.  They buy products to keep up with current trends.  They want to be in a nice home in a nice area and send their kids to quality schools.

Working Class (38%)
- They lead a working class lifestyle at any income level, education level, or job.  They usually will depend on relatives for economic and emotional support, for purchasing advice, and for assistance in rough times.  Family is the most important reference and cultural group.

Lower Class (16%) 
- Upper Lowers: These are the working poor.  Their living standard is just above the poverty line, and they actively strive to advance to a higher class of life.  Often they do not a great education or skills, and they are often poorly paid for unskilled work and tasks.
- Lower Lowers:  These are the visibly poor in society.  They are poorly educated and unskilled.  They are usually out of work and depend on the government for assistance most of the time.  They are in the middle of a day-to-day existence.

It is the marketer's job to not ignore any of the reference groups of our target markets.  We must be constantly researching and identifying these groups, because they will expose people to new lifestyles and behaviors, and change their attitudes and influence the consumer's self-image.  Reference groups are a vital component of our marketing campaigns.

In my next post I will examine other types of social factors.  After that I will look at the VALS Lifestyle Classification System.


Follow @macdailybites

Read More